Westernesse

Name    
Message
Enter Security Code
 

 

Page: [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]...[48]


Name Arehte    
Date 2010-08-07 11:50:11

Message

Hello Helge I am just visiting your site again and read some of your prequel story work. I have a copy of a story of Isildur written by a Brian K Crawford. It is set in the year 3441 covering from April 15 to July 4th. A good bit of work.


Name Travis    
Date 2010-07-31 21:53:16

Message

Helge, I enjoy your dramatization. A few suggestions: 1) The temple is a Gigerized version of the Radcliffe Camera buildling of Oxford; 2) Isildur changes heart by seeing the beauty of the Moon, rather than by seeing the evenstar; 3) Nimloth bursts with white "moon-fire" when ignited; 4) would it be going to far to hear "freedom isn't free" from the mouth of Sauron? 5) Any depictions of the ring-gifted Men before they became Nazguls might include one who is a Middle-earth version of Mordred of Orkney (the Witch-king) and one who is like Ivan the Terrible (perhaps Khamul the Easterling).

P.S. Southron "Maino woc!" is brilliant.


Name walpurgis    
Date 2010-04-18 18:10:37

Message

I have always pictured the war of wrath to be one fought mainly by the maia of the vala and the maia of melkor, in sort of an angelic beings vs demonic beings sort of thing, beings of light against the balrogs, and others of that sort


Name King Arthur    
Date 2010-04-08 17:07:18

Message

Well at least we can leave some comments...
:]


Name asdasd    
Date 2010-03-28 8:24:42

Message

http://news.tvliaoroom.com/modules/planet/view.article.php?216/b0


Name Labrynian Rebel    
Date 2010-03-04 4:40:11

Message

Amazing! What I would do to see this as an actual movie...

On minor gripe though, you mentioned telling that three of the rings sauron had recovered, and four were consumed by dragons? Well that was true by the time of lord of the rings, but in the backstory of the hobbit, the King Under the Mountian still had their ring, and Sauron only recovered it when he dwelled in Dol Gulder, thousands of years after the fall of Numenor. So although it would be nice to mention this, it contradicts too much (especially since the Hobbit will be a movie soon XD)


Name Mephis    
Date 2010-02-08 13:20:40

Message

Not wanting to read through 45+ pages of commentary, I wondered whether anyone had pointed out that the rights to this project would have to be procured from Tolkien's estate - which means going through Christopher Tolkien, who has voiced strong opposition to any film and/or other media adaptation of The Silmarillion outside of his own control.

Perhaps that's a reason why part 3 has never been completed? (Surely someone has referenced this before.)


Name Raven    
Date 2010-01-31 23:54:10

Message

I Give up...this is pointless...


Name Jedi Mind Tricks    
Date 2010-01-31 23:53:04

Message

AND WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE TO TELL ME WHAT
SHOULD I DO,AND WHAT I SHOULDNT?


Name Raven    
Date 2010-01-31 23:51:48

Message

Hey Jedi,No need to get all hysterical!


>>

Back to Westernesse Prequel Movie

 

Guestbook provided by AnvilBook.com
Click here to get your own free guestbook

Dog Names - Google SEO Company